One of our dearest freedoms is that of free speech. It is one of our defining freedoms. Lately there seems to be a fine line being drawn as to what is tolerable free speech. I got into a pretty hot debate a few weeks ago when the news first broke about the rioting in Benghazi and Cairo. I read the news, Benghazi ended up not being a riot but an all out terrorist attack. But, in the first days of coverage all we were being told here in the US is that the Muslim communities in more than one country were “outraged” over this video that popped up on YouTube. My opinion of the video is par with most. It was ridiculous. I will never get back the 15 minutes of my life I wasted wanting to know what all the fuss was about.
I don’t know much about the Muslim faith. From what I have read in effort to remedy that ignorance, I came to understand why this video was so bad. Living in the United States, I’m used to the constant ridicule of religion. It isn’t strange for me to see a movie, skit, music video, cartoon, or whatever take aim at a myriad of different faiths. Our freedom of speech protects the rights of those individuals to express their opinion, regardless of its validity.
Learning more about the Muslim faith and Sharia Law, the whole issue in the middle east became less of a mystery to me. I’ve sort of assumed our involvement in things over there had some merit and basically blindly trusted our leaders. Mistake on my part? Absolutely. But, I’ve fixed that ignorance. I am not going to say I’m an expert on the issues regarding our nation’s foreign policy, but I now understand what the politicians are talking about now. Let me just say, I feel a lot more informed. And I believe I’m a much more educated voter.
Ok. So, this video sparked a bunch of folks to storm embassies around the world. I read stories about the film maker and tried to make sense of what the guy was trying to accomplish. At the conclusion of my amateur investigation, I deduced this guy was doing nothing more than instigating fury. It worked.
As I watched my television screen portray the American flag being burned, a flag of Islam being hoisted in its stead, fires burning, and people screaming and pushing through tear gas, I wondered if what this filmmaker did was the equivalent of yelling “FIRE” in a crowded room. Now please realize this was the thought process as the story developed. Our information about the whole thing is vastly deeper today.
His film was the catalyst to a lot of protest. His personal belief is “...Islam is a cancer.” Again, freedom of speech. He’s allowed to say those things here.
But, I struggle to support his right, when what he did ended up stirring up violence. What do you do? In the name of Free Speech, nothing. Abhor his choice, but defend his right.
Caving to violence isn’t the answer. It would be un-American to punish this guy for exercising his rights. It’s American to defend them.
Within days of this whole issue exploding, I read a statement released by a French magazine publisher, giving the public a head’s up there was to be a cartoon spread in their upcoming issue. That cartoon spread would depict the prophet Mohammad indelicately. WHAT? WHY? read about it here
If you know your words will insight violence, why would you choose to say them? Is hate speech free? Should you be able to say and do things knowing the consequences may cost a life or two, or three, or whatever?
The American way of life is the antithesis of Islam. We gamble, drink, waste, fornicate, blaspheme, all without punishment. In Sharia Law those are all sins. Major ones. Adultery is a big one. There was a case in northern Mali where a couple who wasn’t married but had children together were stoned to death under Sharia Law. There are tons of examples of how our way of life is simply unacceptable to their way of thinking. To them their religion and governing laws are synonymous.
The United States has been a target for decades because of the differences between us and them. They want us dead. Hence, 9/11/01. Among other instances. But the attack on 9/11 was the wake up call for Americans. Just by being who we are, we are targets.
The fact is, even if tomorrow, legislation was passed that prohibited anti-Islam speech, it wouldn’t change the intent of the extremists. I’m not naive enough to even think it’s possible for even a second to change their minds. They hate us. That’s not going to change unless the entire country converts to Islam. Don’t see that happening any time soon. Enter another one of our precious Rights. Freedom of religion.
In the heated conversation I had regarding the freedom of speech, this is what was said.
Me- I think this guy should be held responsible for the deaths of those four Americans. If his video actually sparked this kind of violence, he should be held on manslaughter.
The Other Person (TOP)- Are you kidding me? I want to go out tomorrow and make a video saying nothing but how stupid I think Mohammad is and how he’s a pink fairy.
Me- Why would you do that? When you know it’s going to piss off a whole bunch of unstable people? Do you want to see more violence?
TOP- It’s my right as an American to say whatever the hell I want to say. I don’t care if you live in another country. I don’t live where they live, so why the hell should I be forced to follow their laws? You don’t give the crazies power by letting them tell you how to live your life. If I want to say Islam is a farce and the worst thing that ever happened to the world, it’s my right as an American to say so.
Me- Hmm. I would never say anything that I know would create a problem to that extent.
It went on from there, but mostly just repeating the same things to each other. But, TOP was right. Why should we let a group of people dictate how the rest of the world lives? But at the same time, what can we do to try to curtail the very things that provoke the crazies? Maybe I am a little naive to think we can all just get along. I don’t think we’ll ever be able to. But, maybe sometimes just keeping your mouth shut when you don’t have anything nice to say is a good place to start.
